DIY Milk Alternatives: Complete Guide to Homemade Plant-Based Milks
Master the art of making your own plant-based milk alternatives with our comprehensive guide to homemade nut, seed, and grain milks.
Introduction
There's something magical about pouring homemade plant milk into your morning coffee or watching it blend seamlessly into your favorite cake batter. We've been making our own plant-based milks for years, and we're excited to share everything we've learned along the way.
When we first started baking dairy-free, we relied heavily on store-bought alternatives. But after countless recipe tests (and a few memorable failures), we discovered that homemade versions gave us so much more control over our baking outcomes. Plus, there's something deeply satisfying about creating an essential ingredient from scratch.
Whether you're avoiding dairy for health reasons, ethical concerns, or simply because you ran out of milk mid-recipe, learning to make your own plant-based alternatives will revolutionize your baking. You'll save money, reduce packaging waste, and—most importantly—create baked goods with flavors and textures that might even surpass their dairy-containing counterparts.
In our test kitchen, we've made every mistake possible so you don't have to. We've over-soaked nuts, under-blended oats, and created some truly questionable concoctions along the way. But through all that experimentation, we've developed foolproof methods for creating silky, delicious plant milks that work beautifully in everything from delicate pastry cream to hearty sandwich bread.
Why Make Your Own?
Before we dive into the how-to, let's talk about why homemade plant milks are worth the (minimal) effort:
- Cost savings: We calculated that homemade almond milk costs about $1.50 per quart compared to $3-4 for store-bought versions. That adds up quickly if you bake regularly!
- Customizable thickness: Store-bought milks are typically formulated for drinking, not baking. When we make our own, we can create thicker versions for creamy desserts or thinner ones for everyday baking.
- No additives: Many commercial plant milks contain stabilizers, gums, and preservatives that can sometimes affect baking chemistry. Our homemade versions have none of these.
- Flavor control: We can adjust sweetness, add vanilla, or leave it completely plain depending on what we're baking.
- Environmental impact: Less packaging and transportation means a smaller carbon footprint for your baking projects.
In our years of recipe development, we've found that homemade plant milks often produce superior results in baking. The fresh, clean flavors don't compete with other ingredients, and without stabilizers, they often incorporate more smoothly into batters and doughs.
Let's get started with the equipment you'll need.
Essential Equipment
The good news is that you probably already have most of what you need to make plant-based milks. In our test kitchen, we've tried everything from fancy specialized equipment to the most basic tools, and we've found that simplicity often wins. Here's what you'll need to get started:
The Must-Haves
A Good Blender
This is the one place we don't recommend skimping. While you can make plant milk with an immersion blender in a pinch, a high-powered blender will give you the creamiest, smoothest results. We use our Vitamix almost daily, but any blender with at least 600 watts should work well.
Our tip: If your blender isn't super powerful, soak your nuts or grains for an extra few hours and blend in smaller batches for longer periods.
Straining Equipment
You'll need something to separate the milk from the pulp. We've tried all of these options with success:
- Nut milk bag: Our preferred option. These reusable drawstring bags (usually made from nylon mesh) make straining quick and easy. They cost about $10-15 and last for years.
- Fine mesh strainer: Works well for most milks, especially oat milk. You may need to strain twice for super-smooth results.
- Cheesecloth: In a pinch, several layers of cheesecloth in a regular strainer works fine. It's messier but gets the job done.
- Clean tea towel: The most accessible option! We've used thin, clean dish towels when nothing else was available.
Storage Containers
Homemade plant milks need to be refrigerated and used within a few days. We've found these containers work best:
- Glass bottles or jars: Our favorite option. Mason jars, recycled glass milk bottles, or any container with a tight-fitting lid works well.
- BPA-free plastic containers: Look for ones that seal completely to prevent absorbing refrigerator odors.
Our tip: We like to keep a dedicated funnel in our plant milk kit. It makes transferring the freshly made milk to storage containers much less messy!
Nice-to-Have Extras
- Kitchen scale: For consistent results, weighing your ingredients is more accurate than measuring by volume.
- Large mixing bowl: Having a bowl with a pour spout makes the straining process much cleaner.
- Funnel: As mentioned above, this makes transferring your milk to storage containers much easier.
- Measuring cups and spoons: For measuring add-ins like sweeteners, salt, and flavorings.
- Dehydrator or oven: Not essential, but useful if you want to dry and use the leftover pulp.
Our Real-Life Setup
In our test kitchen, we keep a dedicated "plant milk station" with our blender, two nut milk bags (so one can be in the wash), a wide-mouth funnel, and a set of glass bottles. Having everything in one place makes the process so quick that we often make fresh milk several times a week. The whole process takes less than 10 minutes of active time!
Now that you've got your equipment ready, let's move on to the basic techniques that work for almost any plant milk you want to make.
Basic Techniques
After a lot of experimentation, we've developed an easy method that works for almost any plant milk. While each type has its own nuances (which we'll cover later), this master technique will get you started with confidence.
Plant Milk Recipe
Ingredients:
- 1 cup raw nuts, seeds, or grains
- 3-4 cups filtered water (plus more for soaking)
- Pinch of salt (optional but recommended for baking)
- 1-2 teaspoons sweetener (optional)
- ½ teaspoon vanilla extract (optional)
Basic Steps:
- Soak your base ingredient
- Drain and rinse
- Blend with fresh water
- Strain
- Store properly
Step 1: Soaking
Almost all plant milk bases benefit from soaking, though the time varies dramatically. Soaking serves several important purposes:
- Softens the ingredients for easier blending
- Removes enzyme inhibitors and improves digestibility
- Creates a creamier final product
- Reduces any bitter flavors
| Ingredient | Soaking Time | Water Temperature | Special Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Almonds | 8-12 hours | Room temperature | Skins can be removed after soaking for milder flavor |
| Cashews | 2-4 hours | Room temperature | Can be used without straining |
| Oats | 20-30 minutes | Cold water | Don't over-soak or it becomes slimy |
| Rice | 2 hours | Room temperature | Pre-cooked rice needs no soaking |
| Coconut (shredded) | 1-2 hours | Hot water | Use hot water to help release oils |
| Hemp seeds | No soaking needed | N/A | Can be blended immediately |
Our tip: We often start soaking nuts before bed for morning milk-making, or in the morning for evening baking sessions. If you're in a hurry, you can use hot water and reduce soaking time by about half for most ingredients.
Step 2: Draining and Rinsing
This step is crucial but often overlooked. The soaking water contains enzyme inhibitors and sometimes bitter compounds that you don't want in your milk.
- Drain the soaking water completely
- Rinse the soaked ingredients under cool running water until it runs clear
- For ingredients like almonds, a quick rubbing between your hands can remove skins for a milder flavor (optional)
Our tip: We've found that thorough rinsing makes a noticeable difference in the final flavor, especially for nuts and seeds. Don't skip this step!
Step 3: Blending
Now for the transformation! This is where your ingredients become milk.
- Place your drained and rinsed base ingredient in your blender
- Add 3-4 cups of fresh, filtered water (less water = creamier milk)
- Add any optional ingredients (pinch of salt, sweetener, vanilla)
- Start blending on low speed, then gradually increase to high
- Blend for 1-2 minutes until completely smooth and frothy
Our tip: For baking, we usually add a tiny pinch of salt to our plant milks. It doesn't make them taste salty, but it enhances the natural flavors and helps the milk perform more like dairy milk in recipes.
Ratio Guide for Different Uses
- For drinking: 1:4 ratio (1 cup nuts/seeds/grains to 4 cups water)
- For most baking: 1:3 ratio (slightly creamier)
- For creamy desserts: 1:2 ratio (very rich, similar to half-and-half)
- For "heavy cream" substitute: 1:1 ratio (extremely rich, limited uses)
Step 4: Straining
This step separates the milk from the pulp, giving you that smooth, pourable consistency.
- Place your straining device (nut milk bag, fine mesh strainer, etc.) over a large bowl
- Pour the blended mixture through the strainer
- If using a nut milk bag, gently squeeze to extract all the liquid
- For extra-smooth results, you can strain a second time
Our tip: Don't discard the pulp! We'll share ideas for using it later, but it can be added to baked goods for extra nutrition and reduced waste.
Note: Some plant milks, like cashew milk, can be used without straining if blended long enough in a high-powered blender. We'll note these exceptions in the specific milk sections.
Step 5: Storage
Proper storage is essential for homemade plant milks since they don't contain preservatives.
- Transfer your freshly made milk to a clean, airtight container
- Refrigerate immediately
- Most homemade plant milks last 3-5 days in the refrigerator
- Always shake well before using, as separation is natural
Our tip: We often make smaller batches more frequently rather than large batches that might spoil. For baking projects, we make milk the day before or the morning of baking day for the freshest flavor.
Now that you understand the basic process, let's explore specific types of plant milks and how to optimize them for baking.
Types of Plant-Based Milks
Each type of plant milk brings its own unique properties to your baking. After years of testing, we've discovered which ones work best for different applications. Let's explore the most popular options and how to optimize them specifically for baking.
Almond Milk
Almond milk is probably the most popular plant milk, and for good reason. Its neutral flavor and versatility make it our go-to for many baking projects.
Basic Recipe
- 1 cup raw almonds
- 3-4 cups filtered water
- Pinch of salt
- Optional: ½ tsp vanilla extract, 1-2 tsp sweetener
Soak almonds 8-12 hours, drain, rinse, blend with fresh water, strain.
Baking Properties
- Fat content: Low to moderate
- Protein content: Low
- Flavor impact: Mild, slightly nutty
- Color: Off-white
- Separation tendency: Moderate
Best Uses in Baking
- Excellent for: Quick breads, muffins, pancakes, waffles, cookies
- Good for: Cakes, frostings, simple custards
- Less ideal for: Delicate pastry creams, white cakes where color matters
Recipe Adjustments Needed
When substituting homemade almond milk for dairy milk in recipes:
- Add 1 tablespoon neutral oil per cup of almond milk to compensate for lower fat content
- For recipes that need to brown (like cookies), add 1 teaspoon of maple syrup
- For recipes that need structure (like cakes), add ¼ teaspoon extra leavening agent
Our Favorite Baking Tip
For the best chocolate cake you've ever had, use homemade almond milk with a tablespoon of coffee added. The almond milk's subtle nuttiness enhances the chocolate flavor, while the coffee deepens it. We've converted many dairy-lovers with this trick!
Oat Milk
Oat milk has become our secret weapon for many baking applications. It's economical, environmentally friendly, and has properties that make it uniquely suited to certain baked goods.
Basic Recipe
- 1 cup rolled oats (not instant or steel-cut)
- 3-4 cups cold filtered water
- Pinch of salt
- Optional: ½ tsp vanilla extract, 1-2 tsp sweetener
Soak oats 20-30 minutes in cold water, drain, rinse briefly, blend with fresh cold water for no more than 30 seconds, strain.
Baking Properties
- Fat content: Very low
- Protein content: Low to moderate
- Flavor impact: Mild, slightly sweet
- Color: Creamy white
- Separation tendency: Low
- Special property: Natural thickening ability
Best Uses in Baking
- Excellent for: Yeast breads, pancakes, creamy soups, sauces
- Good for: Muffins, quick breads, some cakes
- Less ideal for: Delicate custards, white frostings
Recipe Adjustments Needed
When substituting homemade oat milk for dairy milk in recipes:
- Add 1-2 tablespoons neutral oil per cup of oat milk for richness
- Reduce other thickeners slightly as oat milk naturally thickens when heated
- Use cold water and don't over-blend to prevent sliminess
- For yeast breads, oat milk can be used as-is (its natural sugars feed yeast well)
Our Favorite Baking Tip
Homemade oat milk makes the most tender sandwich bread we've ever baked. The natural starches in oats help create a soft crumb that stays fresh longer than other plant milks. We use a 1:3 ratio (thicker milk) and add just a tablespoon of olive oil to the dough for the perfect loaf.
Coconut Milk
When we need a plant milk with serious richness, coconut milk is our go-to. It's the highest in fat content of all plant milks, making it perfect for creamy, decadent baked goods.
Basic Recipe
- 2 cups unsweetened shredded coconut
- 4 cups hot water (not boiling)
- Pinch of salt
Soak coconut in hot water for 1-2 hours, blend thoroughly, strain. For extra-rich milk, use less water.
Baking Properties
- Fat content: High
- Protein content: Low
- Flavor impact: Distinct coconut flavor
- Color: Very white
- Separation tendency: High (forms coconut cream on top)
Best Uses in Baking
- Excellent for: Custards, puddings, ice cream, frostings, rich cakes
- Good for: Cookies, quick breads where coconut flavor is welcome
- Less ideal for: Recipes where you don't want coconut flavor, yeast breads
Recipe Adjustments Needed
When substituting homemade coconut milk for dairy milk in recipes:
- No need to add extra fat - coconut milk is already rich
- Consider whether the coconut flavor works with your recipe
- For recipes where you want less coconut flavor, dilute with another plant milk
- Shake or stir well before using as it separates significantly
Our Favorite Baking Tip
For the most incredible dairy-free pastry cream, use homemade coconut milk at a 1:2 ratio (extra thick). The high fat content creates a silky texture that sets beautifully. We add a touch of vanilla bean and lemon zest to complement the coconut flavor rather than trying to mask it.
Cashew Milk
Cashew milk is the unsung hero of homemade plant milks. Its creamy texture and neutral flavor make it incredibly versatile, and it's one of the few that can be used without straining.
Basic Recipe
- 1 cup raw cashews
- 3-4 cups filtered water
- Pinch of salt
- Optional: ½ tsp vanilla extract, 1-2 tsp sweetener
Soak cashews 2-4 hours, drain, rinse, blend with fresh water until completely smooth. Straining optional with high-powered blender.
Baking Properties
- Fat content: Moderate to high
- Protein content: Moderate
- Flavor impact: Very mild, slightly sweet
- Color: Creamy white
- Separation tendency: Low
Best Uses in Baking
- Excellent for: Creamy sauces, white cakes, frostings, custards
- Good for: Most baked goods, especially those needing a neutral flavor
- Less ideal for: Very few limitations; one of the most versatile options
Recipe Adjustments Needed
When substituting homemade cashew milk for dairy milk in recipes:
- For most recipes, cashew milk can be used 1:1 without adjustments
- For extra richness in desserts, make a thicker version (1:2 ratio)
- If using unstrained cashew milk, reduce other fats slightly
Our Favorite Baking Tip
For the silkiest dairy-free frosting, we use unstrained cashew milk made with a 1:2 ratio. The natural creaminess creates a buttercream-like texture without the need for tons of vegan butter. It pipes beautifully and holds its shape at room temperature better than frostings made with other plant milks.
Rice Milk
Rice milk is the most hypoallergenic option, making it perfect for bakers dealing with multiple food sensitivities. While it's the thinnest of the plant milks, it has unique properties that work well in specific applications.
Basic Recipe
- 1 cup cooked white rice (or ½ cup uncooked, then cooked)
- 4 cups filtered water
- Pinch of salt
- Optional: 1 tsp sweetener, ¼ tsp vanilla
Blend cooked rice with water until smooth, strain through fine mesh strainer or nut milk bag.
Baking Properties
- Fat content: Very low
- Protein content: Very low
- Flavor impact: Neutral, slightly sweet
- Color: Translucent white
- Separation tendency: Moderate
Best Uses in Baking
- Excellent for: Light cakes, delicate cookies, allergy-friendly baking
- Good for: Quick breads, pancakes when adjusted
- Less ideal for: Recipes needing richness or structure
Recipe Adjustments Needed
When substituting homemade rice milk for dairy milk in recipes:
- Add 1-2 tablespoons oil per cup of rice milk to compensate for low fat
- For structure in cakes and quick breads, add 1 tablespoon cornstarch per cup
- For recipes that need to brown, add 1 teaspoon maple syrup
- Consider using brown rice for more nutrition and flavor
Our Favorite Baking Tip
Rice milk makes the lightest, most delicate sugar cookies we've ever baked. The low protein content prevents gluten development, resulting in a tender, melt-in-your-mouth texture. We add just a tablespoon of neutral oil to the dough to compensate for the low fat content.
Flavor Variations
One of the joys of making your own plant milk is the ability to customize flavors. Here are some of our favorite variations that work beautifully in baking:
Vanilla Bean
Add the seeds from ½ vanilla bean or 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract to any base milk. Perfect for cakes, cookies, and pastry creams.
Chocolate
Add 2 tablespoons cocoa powder and 2 tablespoons maple syrup to any base milk during blending. Ideal for chocolate cakes, brownies, and hot chocolate.
Cinnamon Spice
Add ½ teaspoon cinnamon, pinch of nutmeg, and 1 tablespoon maple syrup. Perfect for fall baking, French toast, and bread pudding.
Citrus Infused
Add 1 teaspoon fresh citrus zest (lemon, orange, or lime) during blending. Wonderful in pound cakes, scones, and summer desserts.
Sweetener Options
If your recipe calls for sweetened milk, here are our preferred options:
- Maple syrup: Our favorite for its complex flavor and browning properties
- Dates: 2-3 pitted dates added during blending for natural sweetness
- Honey: If not strictly vegan, adds nice floral notes (use half the amount of other sweeteners)
- Coconut sugar: Adds a caramel-like flavor, excellent with oat milk
Now that you're familiar with the different types of plant milks and their baking properties, let's talk about how to store them properly to maintain freshness.
Storage and Shelf Life
One of the biggest differences between homemade and store-bought plant milks is shelf life. Without preservatives or ultra-high temperature processing, homemade versions need proper storage to maintain freshness. Here's everything we've learned about keeping your DIY milk alternatives at their best.
Basic Storage Guidelines
Refrigerator Storage
- Store in airtight glass containers
- Keep at the back of the refrigerator (coldest part)
- Most homemade plant milks last 3-5 days
- Always shake well before using
- Check for signs of spoilage before using
Freezer Storage
- Freeze in ice cube trays, then transfer to freezer bags
- Leave 1/2 inch headspace in containers (milk expands when frozen)
- Lasts up to 3 months in the freezer
- Thaw overnight in refrigerator
- Blend or shake vigorously after thawing to recombine
Shelf Life by Milk Type
Different plant milks have varying shelf lives based on their composition. Here's what we've observed in our test kitchen:
| Milk Type | Refrigerator Life | Freezer Life | Signs of Spoilage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Almond Milk | 4-5 days | Up to 3 months | Sour smell, thickening, unusual separation |
| Oat Milk | 2-3 days | Up to 3 months | Slimy texture, off smell, thickening |
| Coconut Milk | 3-4 days | Up to 3 months | Sour smell, pink or gray discoloration |
| Cashew Milk | 3-4 days | Up to 3 months | Bitter taste, chunky texture, off smell |
| Rice Milk | 3-4 days | Up to 2 months | Sour smell, thickening, bubbling |
Our Freshness Test
We always perform a quick three-part check before using stored plant milk: look, smell, taste. First, examine the milk for unusual separation or discoloration. Next, give it a good sniff—fresh plant milk should smell clean and pleasant. Finally, if it passes the first two tests, take a small taste. If anything seems off, it's better to make a fresh batch than risk ruining your baked goods.
Extending Shelf Life
While homemade plant milks will never last as long as their commercial counterparts, we've discovered a few tricks to maximize freshness:
- Sterilize containers: Wash glass bottles in hot, soapy water and rinse thoroughly, or run through a dishwasher's sanitize cycle.
- Add natural preservatives: A small pinch of salt helps preserve freshness. For sweet applications, a teaspoon of maple syrup can also help extend shelf life slightly.
- Quick-chill method: After making your milk, place it in an ice bath to cool it rapidly before refrigerating. This helps prevent bacterial growth.
- Portion control: Freeze milk in recipe-sized portions so you only thaw what you need.
Storage for Baking Purposes
When making plant milk specifically for baking, we've developed some specialized storage strategies:
Freezing in Recipe-Specific Amounts
We often freeze plant milk in common recipe measurements to make baking easier:
- Ice cube trays (each cube is about 2 tablespoons)
- 1/4 cup portions in small containers
- 1 cup portions for larger recipes
Label each container with the type of milk, date made, and any added flavors or sweeteners.
Make-Ahead Strategies for Baking Day
For the best results in baking, timing is everything:
- Make milk the day before or morning of your baking project for optimal freshness
- For weekend baking, prepare and freeze milk portions during the week
- Thaw frozen milk overnight in the refrigerator for the best texture
Our Favorite Storage Hack
When we're planning a big baking project, we make a double batch of plant milk. We use half for immediate baking needs and freeze the rest in recipe-sized portions. We label each container with the milk type, ratio used (like "cashew 1:3"), and date. This system has saved us countless times when we need just a small amount of plant milk for a recipe!
Using Leftover Pulp
Don't throw away the valuable pulp left after straining your plant milk! It's full of fiber and nutrients that can enhance your baking. Here are our favorite ways to use it:
Nut Pulp Uses
- Dry in oven at 200°F to make nut flour
- Add wet to cookie dough (reduce other liquids slightly)
- Mix into granola before baking
- Blend into smoothies for extra nutrition
Oat & Grain Pulp Uses
- Add to muffin or quick bread batter
- Mix into overnight oats
- Use in veggie burgers as a binder
- Add to pancake batter for extra fiber
Pulp can be stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator for 2-3 days or frozen for up to a month. We often freeze it in tablespoon portions using ice cube trays for easy use in future recipes.
Now that you know how to properly store your homemade plant milks, let's address some common issues you might encounter and how to solve them.
Troubleshooting Guide
Even with the best techniques, homemade plant milks can sometimes present challenges. After years of experimentation (and plenty of mishaps), we've developed solutions for the most common issues you might encounter.
Common Problems & Solutions
Milk Separates Quickly
The Problem: Your freshly made plant milk separates into layers within hours.
Why It Happens: This is completely natural! Without commercial emulsifiers, homemade plant milks will separate as the heavier particles settle.
Solutions:
- Shake well before each use
- Blend with a small amount (¼ teaspoon per quart) of sunflower lecithin
- For baking, separation doesn't matter as you'll be mixing ingredients anyway
- Make smaller batches more frequently
Grainy or Chalky Texture
The Problem: Your milk has an unpleasant grainy or chalky mouthfeel.
Why It Happens: Insufficient blending, inadequate straining, or using ingredients that weren't soaked long enough.
Solutions:
- Blend for longer (2-3 minutes in a high-powered blender)
- Double-strain through a finer mesh or nut milk bag
- Ensure proper soaking time for your base ingredient
- For almonds, removing skins after soaking can reduce graininess
- For immediate use in recipes, add 1 tablespoon of neutral oil to improve mouthfeel
Slimy Oat Milk
The Problem: Your oat milk has a slimy, mucilaginous texture.
Why It Happens: Oats release starches when over-soaked, over-blended, or exposed to heat during processing.
Solutions:
- Use cold water for soaking and blending
- Limit soaking time to 20 minutes maximum
- Blend for only 30-45 seconds
- Don't squeeze the oat pulp when straining (just let it drain naturally)
- Use rolled oats, not instant or steel-cut
Our fix: If you've already made slimy oat milk, you can still use it in baking where the texture won't be noticeable. It works especially well in pancakes and quick breads.
Bitter Taste
The Problem: Your plant milk has an unpleasant bitter aftertaste.
Why It Happens: Some nuts and seeds contain bitter compounds, or you may have used the soaking water in your final product.
Solutions:
- Always discard soaking water and rinse ingredients thoroughly
- For almonds, remove skins after soaking
- Add a tiny pinch of salt to balance flavors
- Add a small amount of sweetener (1-2 teaspoons per batch)
- A few drops of vanilla extract can mask bitterness
- For sunflower seed milk (which can be quite bitter), add 1 Medjool date per cup of seeds
Milk Spoils Quickly
The Problem: Your homemade milk is spoiling faster than expected.
Why It Happens: Without preservatives, homemade plant milks typically last 3-5 days. Contamination, improper storage, or warm temperatures can shorten this timeframe.
Solutions:
- Ensure all equipment is thoroughly cleaned before use
- Store milk in sterilized containers
- Keep milk at the back of the refrigerator, not in the door
- Don't return unused milk to the main container
- Consider freezing portions you won't use within 3 days
- Add a tiny pinch of salt as a natural preservative
Baking Failures
The Problem: Your baked goods aren't turning out right with homemade plant milk.
Why It Happens: Different plant milks have different fat, protein, and sugar contents compared to dairy milk, which can affect baking chemistry.
Solutions by Symptom:
| Baking Problem | Likely Cause | Solution |
|---|---|---|
| Baked goods don't brown | Low protein and sugar content | Add 1 tsp maple syrup per cup of plant milk |
| Dry, crumbly texture | Low fat content | Add 1-2 Tbsp oil per cup of plant milk |
| Dense, heavy result | Low protein for structure | Add ¼ tsp extra leavening agent |
| Doesn't set properly | Low protein for binding | Add 1 Tbsp cornstarch per cup of plant milk |
| Unwanted flavor | Strong-tasting base ingredient | Switch to a more neutral milk (cashew, oat) |
Milk-Specific Troubleshooting
Almond Milk Issues
- Gritty texture: Remove skins after soaking
- Low yield: Blend longer and squeeze bag more thoroughly
- Bitter taste: Use blanched almonds or add a date
Oat Milk Issues
- Slimy texture: Use cold water, blend briefly
- Separates in coffee: Add a tiny pinch of baking soda
- Tastes starchy: Don't over-blend, use rolled oats only
Coconut Milk Issues
- Too watery: Use less water or unsweetened shredded coconut
- Chunky texture: Blend longer, use hot water for soaking
- Overpowering flavor: Blend with a milder milk like rice
Rice Milk Issues
- Too thin: Use less water or add 1 Tbsp cashews
- Chalky texture: Blend longer, strain multiple times
- Bland taste: Add a pinch of salt and ¼ tsp vanilla
Our Biggest Lesson Learned
After countless batches of plant milk, we've learned that each type has its own personality. Rather than trying to make almond milk behave exactly like dairy milk, we've found it's better to embrace its unique properties and adjust recipes accordingly. Sometimes what seems like a "failure" can lead to a delicious new discovery. Our now-famous vegan chocolate cake was born from a batch of almond milk that separated in the batter—creating pockets of moisture that made the cake incredibly tender!
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I make plant milk without a high-powered blender?
Yes! While a high-powered blender yields the creamiest results, you can use a regular blender by soaking your ingredients longer (add 2-4 hours to the recommended time), blending in smaller batches, and blending for longer periods. You may need to strain twice for the smoothest texture.
Why does my plant milk curdle in coffee?
The acidity and heat of coffee can cause plant proteins to coagulate. To prevent this, warm your plant milk slightly before adding it to coffee, add a tiny pinch of baking soda to your milk, or pour the milk into your cup first, then slowly add the coffee.
Can I use the same recipe for all nuts and seeds?
The basic process is similar, but soaking times and water ratios may vary. Softer nuts like cashews need less soaking time than harder ones like almonds. Seeds generally need less water for soaking. Refer to our soaking chart in the Basic Techniques section for specific guidelines.
Is homemade plant milk nutritionally equivalent to dairy milk?
No, the nutritional profiles differ significantly. Homemade plant milks generally have less protein than dairy milk and varying fat content. If nutrition is a concern, consider adding a small amount of hemp seeds to your base for protein or using a blend of different nuts/seeds for a more complete nutritional profile.
Can I reuse the pulp to make a second batch of milk?
While you can make a second, weaker batch from the same pulp, we find it's better to use the pulp in other recipes. The second batch will have significantly less flavor and nutrients. Instead, try drying the pulp to make flour or adding it to baked goods as suggested in our Storage section.
Final Thoughts
Making your own plant milk might seem intimidating at first, but it quickly becomes second nature. The control you gain over ingredients, consistency, and flavor is well worth the small amount of effort involved. Plus, there's something deeply satisfying about creating this kitchen staple from scratch.
We encourage you to experiment with different bases, ratios, and flavors to find your perfect plant milk. Don't be discouraged by initial challenges—each batch gets better as you become more familiar with the process. And remember, even "failed" batches can usually be repurposed in smoothies, baking, or cooking.
The journey to plant-based baking is full of discovery, and making your own milk is a significant step toward creating truly exceptional dairy-free treats. We'd love to hear about your experiences, favorite combinations, and creative uses for homemade plant milks!
Get our Emergency Baking Substitutions Guide free when you join our newsletter. Never be stuck mid-recipe again!
When you sign up, you'll get:
- Exclusive substitution guides
- Weekly articles and recipes
- Troubleshooting tips, tricks, and more
Advertisement